Evil: “October 31” (S1E5)
Evil is a supernatural drama created by Michelle King and Robert King; this review covers “October 31.” The assessors review an exorcism.
Evil is a supernatural drama created by Michelle King and Robert King; this review covers “October 31.” The central cast includes Katja Herbers, Mike Colter, Aasif Mandvi, Michael Emerson, and Christine Lahti. It originally aired under CBS before moving to Paramount+. As of this review, it’s available through Netflix and Paramount+ and its add-ons.
On “October 31,” Ben (Aasif Mandvi) finds himself as the skeptic on a reality TV show while David (Mike Colter) and Kristen (Katja Herbers) assess a woman going through an exorcism. Sheryl (Christine Lahti) watches the kids, leaving a promising date with a mysterious stranger. Unfortunately, one child isn’t who they seem.
What I Like about Evil: “October 31”
This episode introduces Ben’s recurring relationship issue, which will continue throughout the series. In this case, Nicole Shalhoub’s Vanessa builds a natural chemistry, making a believable budding romance.
Further regarding relationships, Sheryl and Leland (Michael Emerson) have an interaction that suggests a certain charm and chemistry. Leland doesn’t express the usual charisma one might find but a competency to sell himself.
David and Kristen’s friendship receives its first real challenge, as Dr. Kristen Bouchard fears the exorcism might kill the patient. As the two have been getting along swimmingly beforehand, this friction seems inevitable considering their vastly different life perspectives.
The formulaic procedural breakdown doesn’t apply perfectly in “October 31,” creating room for experimentation with the show’s core concepts. It also breaks Ben from the trio’s shadow, giving the viewer further insight into his perspective and character. While he’s the furthest of the three from that central plot, he is more than just a side character.
Kristen’s kids (whom I will avoid naming until it becomes relevant) earn a full dedication, earning the episode’s namesake. This episode involves another creepy child who subtly provides hints and plot points for future episodes. One such bit of information is the giant hole in the basement.
The fictitious ghost-hunting show, “Gotham Ghosts,” feels legitimate, boasting a name better than some real shows that follow the same concept. As an interesting edit, some sources call this show “Demon Hunter” for some reason, but I haven’t found out why.
As for the episode’s fear factor, “October 31” possesses a specific kind of fright more relevant to parents as a child leads Kristen’s children away from their home for a few tension-riddled scenes.
Tired Tropes and Triggers
“October 31” provides a lot of apologetics in this episode, which I won’t get into too much depth to avoid any spoilers. However, expect psychology to get that comparison of “differing beliefs.” This idea might linger into justifying the exorcism as the religious argument seems correct. Regardless, there remains ambiguity that allows personal bias to inform opinion.
As mentioned, children find themselves in danger. While nothing comes of this danger other than general anxiety, it’s still a small consideration.
What I Dislike about Evil: “October 31”
Barring a few nitpicks and thoughts, there weren’t any particular issues with this episode. The horror and humor slightly flatten compared to previous episodes, but “October 31” pushes the plot forward as intended.
David initially calls Ben to act as the third party, which seems highly inappropriate considering Ben’s role as the technical solutions expert. Plot-wise, the intent probably aims to show why Ben couldn’t be involved. However, he’s the lead of the B plot, so that seems unnecessary.
Kristen brings in Dr. Boggs (Kurt Fuller) for a second opinion. As a therapist, he certainly holds the qualifications to assess the situation. However, it strikes me as weird that Kristen wouldn’t call in another trusted professional, considering her relationship with Dr. Boggs as her therapist. I imagine this creative decision intends to focus the cast, but it suggests that Kristen lacks connections within her field.
Final Thoughts
“October 31” takes Evil to a Halloween-themed episode nearing the date (October 24th). It challenges the usual formula and provides a potential ghost story. While the horror and comedy leave room for improvement, “October 31” still builds on Evil’s tension and plot.
(3 / 5)
Movies n TV
Evil: Rose390 (S1E4)
Evil is a supernatural drama created by Michelle King & Robert King; this review covers Rose390. The assessors investigate a troubled boy.
Movies n TV
Afraid.
When a family trials a next-generation AI home assistant they get more assistance than they bargained for.
Movies n TV
Evil: 3 Stars (S1E3)
3 Stars is an episode of the supernatural drama, Evil, created by Michelle King and Robert King. The assessors learn of demonic obsession.