Agatha All Along is the latest Marvel Universe show on Disney +. For those who didn’t watch Wandavision, Agatha was the antagonist. She was a witch trapped in Wanda’s town, who decided to steal Wanda’s powers instead of helping the trapped townspeople of Westview.
She also kills Wanda’s dog, before you get too attached to her.
Apparently, this character was just too fun to leave in Westview, though. So now Agatha has her own miniseries, just in time for Halloween.
The story
We begin our story with a small-town detective named Agnes, played by Kathryn Hahn. She’s a loose cannon who plays by her own rules. And yes, that’s exactly the trope they’re beating into the ground. But oh gosh, she’s emotional when she’s called into a case regarding a dead woman in the middle of the woods.
Advertisement
We soon realize that this is not the real world, though. Because Agnes isn’t Agnes. She’s Agatha, trapped in a small-town crime drama thanks to the spell the Scarlett Witch trapped her in.
What worked
When this episode started, I was at first concerned. This show was pitched as a witchy romp down a path to regain stolen powers. At first, it seemed like instead it might be a rehashing of Wandavision, just with darker and less family-focused TV tropes.
Thankfully, this dive into small-town detective show lasted just as long as it needed to. It made fun of the genre, hinted that something was wrong, and then stopped. I’m so glad it didn’t overstay its welcome because it was going to get old fast.
That being said, the callbacks to Wandavision were fun. I especially liked the cameo from Debra Jo Rupp reprising her role.
Seeing Westview through a darker lens was also fun. It would have made a good small town hiding big secrets.
This first episode was also very action-focused. While we needed to get some exposition and emotional setting in there, it was a good idea to get the story started. Some recent Marvel series have been slow to start. And frankly, slow to proceed. I’m glad this one doesn’t seem to have the same problem.
Advertisement
What didn’t work
That being said, I do hope we get more than fun from this series. And so far, this episode was more fun than substance.
Thus far, we don’t have a reason to care about the characters. We know Rio hates Agatha. Or wants to sleep with her. Or both. We don’t know why, but Rio also seems evil so it’s not like we want to root for her.
I am hoping we get more of a storyline as we go through.
Of course, that does bring me to a more serious question about Agatha All Along. Did we need to hear Agatha’s story?
I know villain stories have been all the rage in the last decade. Joker, Venom, Cruella. There’s even a new show coming out about the Penguin.
Do we need everyone’s back story? Does every character have enough to them to tell their own story? Or are they only interesting when they’re in the story of somebody else?
Advertisement
I don’t have high expectations for this show. Don’t get me wrong, I think it’s going to be great fun to watch. It’s high energy, colorful, and funny. But I don’t think it’s going to have the rich, deep staying power like Wandavision. But this is only the first episode. So maybe they’ll surprise me.
“A is for Angel” is an episode of the supernatural drama, Evil, created by Michelle King and Robert King. The central cast includes Katja Herbers, Mike Colter, Aasif Mandvi, Michael Emerson, Christine Lahti, and Andrea Martin. It originally aired under CBS before moving to Paramount+. As of this review, it’s available through Netflix and Paramount+ and its add-ons.
The assessors investigate a potential angelic possession. David (Mike Colter) meets a helpful nun (Andrea Martin as Sister Andrea). Kristen (Katja Herbers) talks to the police. Sheryl (Christine Lahti) takes out her frustration on someone who deserves it. Leland (Michael Emerson) makes a haunting confession.
What I Like about Evil: “A is for Angel”
While “A is for Angel” fears depicting a biblically accurate angel, it still evokes a haunting terror such angels evoke. Brandon J. Dirden’s Raymond/Archangel Michael provides an unsettling performance that directly comments or alludes to actions that angels take in the bible.
This episode introduces Sister Andrea, who will become a key character of the series, acting as a spiritual advisor and mentor to David specifically. She’s interesting enough to evoke lasting memorability, given more attention than debut characters in their introductory episodes.
Leland’s confession to David gets dark, revealing much of the personal relationship the two had before the series began. While nothing remains confirmed, and Leland clearly aims to antagonize David, David’s reaction suggests that some truthful admissions linger within the deception. However, it’s ultimately a viewer’s decision to weigh these claims.
Advertisement
“A is for Angel” creates a rather terrifying dynamic that evokes a haunting narrative. Where the previous episode focused more on what comes next, “A is for Angel” dives into the horrific implications of the procedural plot.
Tired Tropes and Triggers
As mentioned earlier, the procedural plot involves an angelic possession and some Old Testament godliness, which might upset some viewers. Some points suggest sexism and abuse, but little of this receives attention beyond the claim.
A character potentially murdered their wife, suggesting spousal abuse, but the reality of the situation seems blurred. Regardless, the victim tries to leave their abuser, which is a common source of abuse in domestic violence.
While nothing remains confirmed, a child molester apparently receives angelic punishment. The viewer takes the word of the angel’s supposed host on this claim, which hardly means an absolute confirmation.
Suicide, potentially assisted suicide, is another plot point alluded to in the episode. Little remains a proven fact, but the suggestion seems plausible considering what the viewer knows of the situation. As this remains the only confirmation, the claims seem interpretable.
What I Dislike about Evil: “A is for Angel”
Again, “A is for Angel” puts a lot of focus on the horrifying concept of an angel but doesn’t try to depict a biblically accurate angel. Frankly, it’s a wasted opportunity, considering the haunting nature of their descriptions. Such descriptions rival that of Lovecraftian abomination in horrifying potential. It seems like a perfect opportunity for a show or film like Evil. Even as “A is for Angel” challenges the depictions, it hesitates to open its’ trillions of eyes to the opportunities available.
Leland allows the assessors into his home and leaves valuable evidence for the team to find. For such an intelligent character, these oversights seem uncharacteristic. Viewers might assume this frantic response is a ploy, but his reactions suggest otherwise.
Advertisement
Final Thoughts
“A is for Angel” returns Evil to the horror roots that the previous episode hadn’t lingered on. The episode unravels some mysteries of the past that better contextualize relationships. If you’re eager for Old Testament godly intervention, this episode brings out a proper dose of it. (3 / 5)
Welcome to Nightvale is an incredibly popular podcast created by Joseph Fink and Jeffrey Cranor. It’s well-loved by horror and fantasy fans alike.
I think it’s, well, fine.
The book Welcome to Nightvale is the first of a series about the same nameless Midwestern town. And it was, well, not that great.
The story
We begin our tale with Jackie. She’s a nineteen-year-old who works at the pawn shop in Nightvale. She has been a nineteen-year-old for decades. Her life is simple. She works and she goes home. At home, she doesn’t do much but listen to the radio.
Advertisement
That is until a strange man comes to her shop.
Meanwhile, a mother named Diane is struggling with her son. He is a shapeshifter, and also a teenager. He appears to be struggling with both. Diane is trying to help him, but he doesn’t want her help. She’s feeling unloved and unappreciated. Which makes sense, because he is sure acting like he doesn’t love or appreciate her.
Then, his father returns to town.
What worked
The Nightvale world is, if nothing else, a creatively dark world full of illogical Eldridge horrors. There are simply dark things lurking, without any rhyme or reason. Fantastical and horrifying people live side by side with literal miracles. This is easily the most entertaining part of the whole book.
What didn’t work
That being said, all the lovely world-building in the world isn’t worth anything if there isn’t a decent story in place. It’s like a gorgeous set for a play that goes nowhere.
Advertisement
And it felt very much like this story went nowhere. Or, at least it took forever to go anywhere.
The story felt incredibly repetitive. For instance, we went over and over how Jackie was nineteen and had been nineteen for decades. We didn’t need to do that. It’s bad enough that she’s choosing to not move forward in her life. We don’t need to experience it with her.
This over-explanation kind of killed the one part of the story I liked. It took all the fantastical, unexplainable parts of the story and killed them with over-explanation.
Maybe this wouldn’t have mattered as much if I had been gripped by the characters. But I just wasn’t. Both Jackie and Diane felt boringly real, despite their fantastical lives. They seemed stuck in their ways and unwilling to do anything to change them. And that is just not a character that I want to read about.
In the end, this just isn’t Fink’s best work. If you’re looking for something great from him, read Alice Isn’t Dead.
Advertisement
Or maybe it’s just not for me. I, after all, appear to be the only person on the planet who doesn’t like this podcast. If you enjoy the Welcome to Nightvale podcast, you might enjoy this book. But if you’re just looking to start your Halloween reading, there are better options.
“N is for Night Terrors” is an episode of the supernatural drama, Evil, created by Michelle King and Robert King. The assessors assess a friend of the Cardinal.
“N is for Night Terrors” is an episode of the supernatural drama, Evil, created by Michelle King and Robert King. The central cast includes Katja Herbers, Mike Colter, Aasif Mandvi, Michael Emerson, and Christine Lahti. It originally aired under CBS before moving to Paramount+. As of this review, it’s available through Netflix and Paramount+ and its add-ons.
The assessors assess a donor and personal friend to the Cardinal. Kristen (Katja Herbers) confesses to Dr. Boggs (Kurt Fuller). David (Mike Colter) struggles to balance his work and studies. Ben (Aasif Mandvi) meets a demon.
What I Like about Evil: “N is for Night Terrors”
Kristen returns from her season 1 finale with a strangely unreliable playfulness. With what the viewer knows, the performance creates an unnerving new norm for season 2 to unpack. While subtle, the trauma creates a domino effect across all her relationships. Everyone knows something’s off, even if they don’t understand what.
Leland receives the most material to execute, allowing him ample opportunity to build meaningful hostile relationships with all three assessors. The viewer sees a perfect example of this through his new interactions with Ben, with whom Leland had no previous direct interactions.
David further indulges in dangerous behaviors to evoke his visions, replacing his old habits with pain to access these visions with renewed clarity. David needs God’s attention, forcing him into unhealthy cycles. It’s a particularly unsettling pattern to witness.
Advertisement
As Ben is the least affected by the supernatural forces in the show so far, “N is for Night Terrors” sets season 2 as the correction of this grievous error. This dynamic creates a synergy between the first and second seasons, having already built Ben as the least tolerable to the supernatural shenanigans.
Of all the seasons, season 2 establishes my personal favorite title gimmick across the seasons. While some episodes of season 1 have great titles that tie in the episode’s procedural plot, season 2 achieves this standard while matching the tone and overarching plot.
Tired Tropes and Triggers
Leland directly abuses the bureaucracy of the Catholic church to get what he wants. While season 1 explores potential corruption in the Catholic church, “N is for Night Terrors” shows this corruption in action.
As mentioned above, David uses pain to activate his visions. It’s clearly shown as a negative with real repercussions on the body, but it does work. This won’t be a lasting solution for David’s visions, but that doesn’t help “N is for Night Terrors” communicate the toxicity of this behavior. Aside from this claim, one moment shows the toxicity of this behavior as David misses a call from the person he’s attempting to help.
What I Dislike about Evil: “N is for Night Terrors”
The episode begins with a recap but also lingers on the ending of season 1 after this recap. It seems a strange point to linger on. The streaming era makes this a more exaggerated issue as a viewer gets bombarded with the same information three times.
Because of the personal relationship that all but one of the assessors have with the subject they are assessing, it seems inappropriate that they would continue assessing them. The more obvious their bias, the less sensible Bishop Marx seems when he keeps them on this assignment.
Lastly, the focused trajectory of season 1 takes a backseat to the procedural plot. While it’s an understandable writing decision, it does step back from the initial focus. In a structural sense, this deviation becomes an obstacle specifically placed in their way, but it does reduce tension.
Advertisement
Final Thoughts
“N is for Night Terrors” re-accompanies the viewer with the dynamics of the Evil series following season 1. It plays a little too safe, afraid of expanding too much beyond the refamiliarization, but it adds a few new dynamics for season 2 to follow. (2.5 / 5)
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.