The mind can play tricks on us, and Neil Marshall’s The Descent hints at this throughout its 100 minutes. As 6 women end up trapped in a cave, it seems they are alternately at odds with each other. They are also frequently attacked by underground, humanoid creatures called “crawlers.” So there’s personal drama, monsters, and also the frightening task of escaping an uncharted cave with limited equipment. That’s a formula for disaster, and also for mental breakdown. The Descent does a good job of highlighting how nature sort of screwed us by making us intellectually and emotionally intelligent. Sometimes we “lose it” precisely when we need to have it all together.
Sarah’s Mental Collapse: An Interesting Theory
“Crazy fan theories” can be annoying sometimes, no doubt about. However, the idea that Sarah (Shauna Macdonald) basically snaps and imagines the monsters is too tasty to overlook. In fact, one needn’t have the film so fresh in mind to see the possibilities and recall how there are strong hints of her subtle mental state. It also potentially makes it a monster movie without true monsters, if one wishes to see things this way. It becomes far more of a psychological thriller/adventure-horror story. Just imagine Sarah going nuts and killing all her fellow explorers, due to her fragile condition.
The Complexity of Two Endings
The Descent has two different endings: The U.S. ending and the UK ending. Frankly, the U.S. ending isn’t that great and doesn’t pair well with this article premise. The UK version, on the other hand, lends considerable weight to the prospect of Sarah’s diminished sanity. At first, she imagines (or vividly hallucinates) escaping the cave. While that’s not the craziest thing of all time, it’s a sign that one’s mind isn’t at 100% reality-level. Then, of course, Sarah sees her daughter (Molly Kayll) is also in the cave, along with a birthday cake. Well, it turns out she’s only there with a flashlight, her sadness, and her fear. Or is she alone? She seems to have crawlers around her, ready to lunge at any time and end her time in the cave.
However, if these crawlers truly are imaginary for her, why does she see them so vividly? Well, trauma may be able to work that way for some people. After all, the cave escape was vivid enough for the character. It could be that she lost her mind and started killing off her entourage. Perhaps the craziest thing is that, honestly, such a thing may be plausible.
People truly are fully capable of imagining things that aren’t there, and of acting upon 100% bonkers beliefs. Could being trapped in a cave bring such delusions out to the forefront? Of course! So, at the end of the day, this little fan theory is not only less annoying than others but actually has some plausibility. It probably even makes the movie look smarter because plenty of new questions can emerge. Basically, this theory is not so very crazy, and The Descent isn’t just about a descent into some cave.
What are your thoughts on The Descent and this interesting theory? Let us know in the comments!
I don’t understand why so many people have written these “the crawlers were part of Sarah’s imagination and Sarah killed all of her friends, the crawlers didn’t even exist” theories about The Decent in recent years, like 2020 onwards, when The Decent 2 (the sequel) came out in 2009, and if you’ve watched it, that will prove that the crawlers are real. The ending of the sequel for sure proves that the crawlers were real. Does everyone posting these theories truly have no idea that there was a sequel? I would think they would have at least googled it to find out whether or not there was a sequel before posting.
“But Brannyk,” you may be thinking, “what am I supposed to do now that I am no longer a real being? How shall I spend my days?”
Unfortunately, the government has not released a handbook for this occasion, so I thought we could brainstorm together.
I’m sure it’s lost in the mail…
BECOME A GHOST
There are some benefits to being a ghost, for sure.
No rent or insurance payment. No corporate job, no cleaning cat litter, no AT&T trying to sell you another line after repeatedly telling them that you just want to make sure that your autopayment is on, but they’re all like, ‘Why would you pass up such a bargain on a second line? Are you an idiot?Why wouldn’t you need another phone line?‘ and so you have to tell them, “Because I’M DIVORCED, ASSHOLE, THANKS FOR REMINDING ME OF THAT!”
Or, my absolute biggest pet peeve, when you’re practicing for the ghost speed chair-stacking championship and the normies just don’t appreciate your cool skills.
The cool thing is that they come in all shapes and sizes.
Look at that face and tell me they’re not having the time of their lifeThese are literally just rock monstersYou can be…whatever the fuck they are….No. I’m not making the joke.
Monsters are generally misunderstood. Some have their fans. Others are hated.
So basically, just like people, except with more tentacles.
The only downsides are that you might be too big or too “ick” for some people (these can also be pluses), you may have a taste for human flesh (no judgement), or the biggest issue – there are too many choices.
You could get stuck trying to figure out what kind of monster you are. If you’re not into labels, it’s an absolute nightmare. Or if you’re like me, it’ll be like standing in Subway for 15 minutes trying to figure out what toppings and dressings you want while the “sandwich artist” is openly judging you.
(4 / 5)
I like the customization, but it can be a bit too overwhelming.
BECOME A CRYPTID
Hear me out. I know it seems a lot like the monster category, but it’s not quite.
Cryptids are weird and mysterious. They keep to themselves. They have people who are fascinated by them and post on Reddit about them. Some have people making documentaries about them.
They’re like monsters’ quieter cousin who reads books in the corner at family gatherings. They collect shiny things they find by the side of the road. Sometimes they’ll steal a peanut butter sandwich or two.
Each one kinda has their own goals and priorities. Their own hangouts and interests. But unlike monsters, they’re not looking to rock any boats-
oh, uh…
Never mind, I stand corrected.
(5 / 5)
I like the freedoms of being a cryptid and also dig the cottage-core vibe I get from them.
CONCLUSION: LET’S BE REAL FOR A SECOND…
I know it’s hard right now. It’s going to be hard. You may not exist to some assholes, but you are real. You have real feelings and thoughts and dreams. You have a real future. You have real decisions. Real actions that affect this world.
You have the real ability to wake up tomorrow and choose to exist. And for whatever reason you choose. Use it. Ghosts and monsters and cryptids are powerful, just like you are, even when you don’t feel like it. They have a place in our human world, just like you do. You make this world interesting and important.
You are part of this world, you are real, and you are not alone.
The horror community is one of acceptance, diversity, creativity and passion. In these times, it needs to be. We need to rely on each other. We need to cultivate and protect each other, as much as we need to protect ourselves.
And it looks like I’ll be coming out of my own cryptid hovel I’ve spent the past few years in to remind you that. My job isn’t done. Not by a longshot. And neither is yours.
If you live in the United States, it’s time to rock the vote for real. I shared this video before in conjunction with my identity-based costume work, and I feel it’s important to revisit now, with the election coming up in just a few days. Besides which, Jack Black and Tenacious D are brilliant and given the current political climate, who doesn’t want to do the time warp? But seriously, get out and rock the vote, your life kinda does depend on it (at least insomuch as being able to make for yourself the life that you want, without the government telling you how to do so – especially if you live on the fringes of socially acceptable awkwardness like me and so many of my friends).
tenacious d rock-y the vote
Besides which, this video is so good, it’s worth sharing again anyway. And again, if for some reason the video doesn’t load, you can find it here.
Tow Away Zone photograph of sign and flag as found by Jennifer WeigelTow Away Zone photograph in flag form
Art Attack
And here are some artworks I made awhile back as political commentary. The photograph was shot of the scene exactly as found, of a sign above a parking lot in a quickly gentrifying neighborhood making sure all knew that any unauthorized vehicles were unwelcome, and hung right in front of a flag that was tattered and torn from being caught on the chain link fence driving the point home. The flags were meant to be interactive, with gallerygoers waving them while singing The Star Spangled Banner in its elitist entirety. The whole really spoke to me regarding some of the political climate at the time (this was right before Trump was elected President the first time). How much has changed since then? In some ways, a lot. In other ways, I guess we shall see.
So on my recent road trip to Miami AZ USA for my menstruation art installation, we decided to detour to Roswell NM en route home. To be honest, this was one of the best decisions of my life, up there with road trippin’ from Arizona to San Francisco along CA-Highway 1, and I will go into the details of why here soon.
Some of the signs: Roswell NM
Roswell NM USA has totally embraced its alien history of the UFO crash in the late 1940s and subsequent government cover up. The whole town is alien-happy with beautiful hand carved wood totems, murals and statues everywhere celebrating otherworldly denizens of all types, though predominantly the gray aliens of the crash (and their green counterparts). Even the city logo features a flying saucer as the center of the letter “R”. It really is kind of incredible.
Alien crash site photo opportunity
One of the biggest draws is the International UFO Museum and Research Center, housed in the wonderful old theater building. This museum details the crash history as well as celebrating aliens in movies and media and examining newer alien sightings and abductions. It is very thorough and includes maquettes, statues, written accounts and an extensive research library, as well as an interesting art collection of various items.
Alien landing
And there are TONS of fun alien themed curiosity shops. I will give a shout out to the newer Invasion Station north on Main Street where there had once been an old car dealership. I love the quirky nature of this particular store as well as their strong desire to promote local artists. Most of their wares are hand-painted in NM and feature designs by prominent local artists including one of the lead muralists in town (I bought a magnet of his). They also feature really alternative kitsch like KISS and Ace Frehley alien bobbleheads, marijuana and anal references, and such. All in all, our own Haunted MTL’s kinda folks…
Portrait at Roswell Visitor Center
And the city is a huge tourist draw internationally, so you can meet some amazing and interesting folks from all walks of life who have caught the alien bug or at least want to check out all the hype. As a result of the tourism, the residents seem really laid back and accommodating (kind of like Hawaii but not quite as much) and there is a thriving art scene. And it’s totally my kind of art – weird and a little creepy. Anyway, I feel like I’ve finally found my peeps and am eager to return someday.
Portrait of myself with dark makeup and crow skull headdress, backlit by the sun.
If you’re feeling a bit extraterrestrial, I invite you to also check out some of my alien-themed stories here on Haunted MTL: LTD UFOs among us; my Drive-By short story; and LTD Abducted.
Adam Johnson
March 9, 2021 at 9:46 pm
I think you are right. The UK ending supports the idea that Sarah has descended into madness and I think killed all of them.
A
September 4, 2022 at 3:13 pm
I don’t understand why so many people have written these “the crawlers were part of Sarah’s imagination and Sarah killed all of her friends, the crawlers didn’t even exist” theories about The Decent in recent years, like 2020 onwards, when The Decent 2 (the sequel) came out in 2009, and if you’ve watched it, that will prove that the crawlers are real. The ending of the sequel for sure proves that the crawlers were real. Does everyone posting these theories truly have no idea that there was a sequel? I would think they would have at least googled it to find out whether or not there was a sequel before posting.