Graphic Content #12: Just Swamp Things – Issue 3
Welcome back to the Haunted MTL comic review column, Graphic Content, as we continue our special series that covers just Swamp Things! This week we cover the third issue of the comic which introduces a character who would become nearly iconic to the series as ol’ Swampy himself. So, what does Swamp Thing #3 offer?
Swamp Thing #3 (March 1973)
Swamp Thing #3, or “The Patchwork Man” is another issue credited to Len Wein as the writer and “Berni” Wrightson as the artist. The issue is a direct follow-up to the second issue. You can, as always, find this issue in the collection Swamp Thing: Dark Genesis. Please order it through your local comic shop!
Issue Impressions
The story continues the intense Frankenstein-vibes that have haunted the series since the first issue. Swamp Thing finds himself seeking a cure within the castle of Anton Arcane. He falls through a floor and is nearly rescued by the mysterious Patchwork Man, first seen at the end of the previous issue. Matt Cable, obsessively pursuing Swamp Thing, arrives in the same village where Swamp Thing is. There Matt encounters, conveniently enough, one miss Abigail Arcane, adopted niece of Anton Arcane. All the while, we learn more about the strange Patchwork Man, who is none other than Grigori Arcane – Anton’s brother and Abigail’s father – who was forged into a misshapen monster by Anton.
The plots converge when a disassociated Patchwork Man attacks Matt, carrying off Abigail, only to find himself confronted by Swamp Thing for the requisite fight sequence. The usage of the second person puts the reader in the head of Grigori, unable to communicate his thoughts to others, but they become clear to the reader, creating a sad, grim irony. Eventually, Swamp Thing and The Patchwork Man clash as Swamp Thing sees an imperiled Abigail Arcane. Their fight is ultimately broken up by a pitch-fork and torch-bearing mob, led by Matt. Soon enough, Abigail finds herself holding on for her life across a chasm at the site of Arcane castle when the two monsters come to an unspoken agreement to save her. The Patchwork Man falls to his apparent death, while Swamp Thing hands over Abigail to Matt and the villagers.
Wrightson’s Balkan setting is just vague enough to work but can be comically non-specific with signage in English, for example. Mercifully, the village feels modern enough and does not dip into Balkan cliches. It ultimately is the mountains in the background that does most of the heavy lifting on the setting, here. The work on the characters is fantastic as ever: Abigail is striking with white hair and a black streak, something that may look strange on the screen but works quite well in the comics. She is also drawn with the necessary sex appeal that would eventually work its way into a film adaptation of the series, where Heather Locklear would play Abigail. The real draw of this issue is the contrasting looks of Swamp Thing and The Patchwork Man, however. The hulking mass of Swamp Thing, generally expressed as monstrous within the comic is firmly rendered as heroic whereas The Patchwork Man, crude and misshapen, is at first glance quite horrific. His tragic truth, his life as Grigori, runs counter to the design in a very endearing way. By the end of the issue, you feel for the misshapen creation of Anton Arcane. Again, not unlike Victor Frankenstein and his Creature. Pitiable, sure, but still fairly gross.
Major foundations are laid down in this issue. The tenuous relationship between Matt Cable and Swamp Thing gets its first moment of their future, albeit strained alliance. Abigail is introduced and, in a somewhat strange turn, joins Matt to travel to the US, her justification sort of working. Overall, this is a fine issue, definitely stronger than the second issue, “The Man Who Wanted Forever.” The conflict is more compelling and Grigori Arcane is a more well-rounded figure than Anton Arcane was. Grigori is the heart of the issue, driving the narrative. Len Wein turns the focus from Swamp Thing to this new, strange monster, which is a good move given the relatively basic plot that the character of the Swamp Thing engages with. Swamp Thing, ironically enough, does not need to be the focus of Swamp Thing all the time.
Swamp Seeds
As for where this series fits in with the lore of Swamp Thing, here is a very brief list.
- I definitely cannot say enough about Abigail Arcane, who after Swamp Thing and Matt Cable makes for one of the longest-tenured characters in the series and has romantic links to both of them. Linda doesn’t necessarily count because she spends a lot of time… well, dead.
- A fun fact about Abigail is that she is one of the few DC characters that ages in real-time due to her being part of the now-defunct Vertigo imprint. She is around 17 years old in this issue and was around 50 years old in 2005. Her age has probably regressed due to recent company and imprint changes, however.
- The Arcane family will haunt the pages of Swamp Thing for decades to come, but this is not the last time we see The Patchwork Man, though it won’t be until the 1980s. (Vol. 2 #59) We see Anton again here, in flashback, but he will not make a proper return until issue #10 of volume one.
- Look, I am going to bring up Frankenstein a lot over the coming weeks. So many nods: the angry mob with torches and pitchforks, sure, but there is also Grigori’s memory of Abigail as a little girl.
We are back to comic reviews in next week’s Graphic Content. For now, please share your thoughts on the column, issue, or just about anything Swamp Thing-related.
Thanksgiving is coming up this week if you live in America. And many of us are going to be in contact with younger relatives. And some of you might be on a mission to be the cool/bad influence relative that introduces them to the horror genre. If so, I have just the graphic novel for you.
Published in September of 2023, Hide is based on the novel of the same name by Kiersten White. It was adapted into a graphic novel by Scott Peterson, and illustrated by Veronica and Andy Fish. It tells the story of fourteen people who believe they are in a reality show, playing Hide and Seek in an abandoned theme park. It should surprise absolutely no one to find out that the creators of the show have something much darker in mind.
The story
Our main character is Mack. She’s had about the worst rough start to life one could imagine and is currently living in a homeless shelter. There, she’s given the opportunity to participate in a game show, playing hide-and-seek.
I like to think that if the shelter manager had known of Mack’s horrific past, she wouldn’t have ever made that suggestion.
Mack signs up and soon finds herself in an abandoned amusement park with thirteen strangers. The rules are simple. Hide during the day, and be the last person found. Of course, this is nothing but a lie. There will be no winners, only victims.
What works
The first thing we have to talk about is how Hide the graphic novel compares to Hide, the original book. Of course, there wasn’t going to be enough room for every single part of the story. There were some cuts. But it doesn’t feel like anything essential was cut here. The characters remain the same. The storyline is still there, sans any structural issues. Often, this is a difficult thing to do. Some stories don’t translate from one medium to another. But Peterson did a wonderful job.
Of course, we can’t talk about a graphic novel without talking about the art. And the art in this book is fantastic. The colors are rich and vibrant. Everything looks exactly like one might picture it when reading the novel.
Except for the monster, which I have to admit I pictured more like a Rat Creature from Bone.
My favorite part was the journal entries. I loved the cryptic sigils that are scribbled over the page without explanation. I loved the different handwriting. I loved the clippings of newspapers and pictures. The whole thing was just wonderfully, eerily, immersive.
Finally, I want to point out that Hide is a great graphic novel even if you’ve never read the book, and never intend to. This is not a companion for the book. It tells the story all on its own. And yes, reading a graphic novel is just as valid as reading any other novel. This is just a good story, with good artwork. No other reading is necessary.
What didn’t work
There was only one thing I didn’t love about Hide. And that was the ending.
It’s usually the ending.
In the novel, the ending is ambiguous but satisfying. This ending was, without ruining it, a little more ambiguous. There are questions I really wanted answers for that I didn’t get. There is at least one character that I’d like to know about. Are they okay? I don’t know. And this ending doesn’t even really give us a hint. All we can do is hope.
If you are going to be picking this up for a younger person, be aware that there is some rough language. There are also a few graphic scenes of violence, so if that’s the sort of thing that will get you banned from further holiday events, be aware. But if you have a tween or teen who needs to be encouraged to delve into the creepy side, Hide is a great way to do it. Of course, there’s no shame in just reading it yourself.
(4.5 / 5)
Book Reviews
Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors, a Book Review
Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors is a graphic novel by Plastiboo, acting as the “official guide for a game that doesn’t exist.”
Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors is a graphic novel by Plastiboo. The team behind the work includes Plastiboo as the artist, Hollow Press as the publisher, Michele Nitri as the editor, Christian Dolz Bayarri as the graphic designer, Marco Cirillo Pedri as the graphic supervisor, and E.R. as the English editor and proofreader. The Vermis collection seems sold out in its current editions, but I still recommend ordering from the original publisher, Hollow Press.
Who stares back from the dark glass? The Wayfarer travels–cursed and haunted by their past–through the distant lands and places within the Mist & Mirrors. Endure a corrupt world and struggle to fend off the curses that mark you. Venture forth, Wayfarer, and perhaps find peace and salvation.
What I Like about Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors
The premise remains an “official guide” to a game that does not exist. However, one key distinction that stands out is the corrosion of this “official guide” mark, suggesting Mist & Mirrors centers itself as a graphic novel. In this sense, it more accurately hits its vision while providing an engaging story.
Mist & Mirrors places its character selection at the end of the graphic novel, instead, choosing a character and allowing the reader to follow that journey. While this moves away from the “official guide” concept, it better fleshes out the world and creates a more independent product.
Where Vermis I held a heavy retro-game aesthetic, Vermis II takes this to the next level while adding a wider range of color than the original. Not only does this add more aesthetic variety, but it also vastly improves readability. My greatest critique of the first graphic novel was the general lack of readability that impacted the experience, but Mist & Mirrors seems to take this to heart. Beyond the variety and improvement, the design changes the color themes to match the distinct lands the “Wayfarer” embarks on, giving a direct purpose to the changes.
On starting the graphic novel, I half expected a spiritual successor set in a new world. While its setting certainly differs from the original, Mist & Mirrors expands on the lore and history. In fact, the exploration of Mist & Mirrors adds value to the original and encourages a re-read. Honestly, that’s what all sequels strive (or should strive) to succeed.
Despite the colorful innovation, Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors delivers that same bleak horror popularized by Dark Souls. It still wears its inspirations on its sleeves while better communicating its “game mechanics.”
Tired Tropes and Triggers
Again, there aren’t many points worth mentioning regarding tropes or triggers. As the graphic novel takes themes and trends from the Soulslike genre, it’s dark and bleak but not overwhelmingly so.
Payment and delivery (for American audiences) still come with a 15 to 45-day wait period with little room for verification or updates. The process through PayPal remains seamless, and I received the novel within the timeframe, but it’s a consideration.
What I Dislike about Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors
While there are notable points to mention in this section, Mist & Mirror vastly mitigates Vermis I’s core issues. However, that isn’t inherently the same as fixing them in some cases. For example, readability remains a slight issue. I will emphasize it as a slight issue with the vast improvements implemented.
For those fans of the specific niche that Vermis aims to deliver, Mist & Mirrors tones down the “official guide” aspect. Instead, it favors a more straightforward narrative that follows a specific character. This brings life to the “game world” and makes an independent product but limits Vermis I’s game guide concept.
On a more personal note, I did enjoy the concept of Vermis I’s classes over the classes of Mist & Mirrors. Naturally, there are some interesting concepts, but nothing haunts me like the Infant Seeker or Rat Man. However, the new choices seem to provide a stronger narrative and backstory.
Final Thoughts
Vermis II: Mist & Mirrors vastly improves in many aspects of the original, telling a story set in its bleak and fascinating world. While it does veer from the original concept, it does so to make a more independent product. If you are looking to lose yourself in a strange world or dive deeper into Vermis’ underexplored lore, Mist & Mirrors seems tailor-made for you.
(5 / 5)
Published in April of this year, Bad Dreams in The Night is a collection of horror comics by the artist and author Adam Ellis. With the description stating that it is a graphic novel version of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark, I had to get my hands on it. And it did not disappoint.
The stories
Bad Dreams in the Night consists of eleven short horror stories. I honestly don’t think there’s a bad one in the whole bunch. So let’s just highlight a few.
Easily my favorite story in the book was Little House in the Sea. It’s a sweet, eerie little tale that seems like a pinprick view into a dark and horrifying world. It left me with so many questions that I fear will never have answers. The story is about a young woman and her mother, who live on a little island all alone. The young woman is never to ask about what is on the other side of the sea. Then, her mother dies. And everything changes, but not by a lot.
Green Ribbon was another great story. It’s a retelling of the classic Girl With a Ribbon story from the original Scary Stories book, in which a man is confused and eventually angry that the love of his life wears a ribbon around her neck and won’t tell him why. I liked this updated version. It’s a stark reminder that just because we marry someone, we aren’t owed all of their secrets.
What worked
Of course, the first thing I have to point out about Bad Dreams in the Night is the fantastic artwork. Ellis was a cartoonist first, and it shows.
The artwork is part of the storytelling as well. The best example of this is the story Better Kate Than Never. The younger sister character, Taffy, has such an animated face during the scenes with a ‘studio audience’. When she is just herself, her face is flat, and far more mature than we’d expect for a girl her age.
Though, I suppose based on the story, she might be any age.
Another really enjoyable thing was the mini-essays at the end of each story. As a creator myself, I love the little peeks into the creative process. I know how I come up with stories. But it’s different for everyone, and the story behind the story is often just as fun.
Finally, I have to praise a feature that applies to Ellis’s work overall, not just this book. Whenever he writes scary stories (and he has posted quite a few on his social media) they are a fascinating blend of cute and horrifying. The artwork always has a lovely, innocent, cartoonish look. The children always look like cartoon children, with exaggerated large heads and wide circular eyes.
At the same time, Ellis doesn’t pull any punches when it comes to the blood and gore. One story in particular, Milk Door, is a perfect example of this. I don’t want to spoil the ending for you, but it is graphic, horrifying, and wonderful.
What (kind of) didn’t work
I only have one issue with this book. If you follow Ellis on social media, you’ve likely seen at least some of these stories before.
Though, even as I say this, I’m not sure what could have been done about it. Only the beginnings were shown on Instagram. This was a marketing tactic and an effective one. You get the setup for free, but you have to read the book for the punchline.
Bad Dreams in the Night was a really enjoyable way to spend a few hours. In the end, my only real complaint is that it could have been longer. But of course, that is one of the chief rules of entertainment. Always leave people wanting more.
(usr 5)
By the way, if you like this you might enjoy my haunted apartment novella, Quiet Apocalypse. The main character is a modern witch, and I share some real magic in this fictional story of an unexpected end of the world.
-
Book Reviews7 days agoWhat Feasts at Night: An amble through Romanian folklore.
-
Movies n TV6 days agoFreak Out, a Rocky Horror Memoir by Jennifer Weigel
-
Movies n TV5 days ago
Dexter lives in Original Sin, And In the Beginning
-
Book Reviews5 days agoDepression + Apocalype = ?: This Is Not a Test Book Review
